By clicking on ads or affiliate links we may earn a small commission at no additional cost to you. Learn more...

πŸ¦ͺπŸ”ͺ The Top 5 Best Oyster Shucking Knives

If you’ve ever had to shuck an oyster with a screwdriver or a regular knife then you should know just how valuable a good oyster shucking knife can be. In addition to saving time and being safer, it also prevents cracks and damage to the meat itself by offering an easy and painless way to pry open the oysters. But with all the different types of oyster shucking knives out there it can be difficult to find the perfect option which is why we’ve reviewed the best options on the market and came up with a list of the five best you can order online today.



Our Top Overall Pick




ImageNameFeaturesPrice
Dexter New Haven Style Oyster Knife
  • Blade Length: 2.75"
  • Made in the USA.
  • High carbon & alloy blade.
  • NSF Certified.
  • Bent-tip.
Check Price
OXO Good Grip Oyster Knife
  • Stainless steel blade.
  • Made in China.
  • Bent tip for easier prying.
  • Soft and slip-resistant handle.
  • 100% Dishwasher safe.
Check Price
Victorinox Oyster Knife
  • Blade Length: 2.75"
  • Made in Switzerland.
  • Ergonomic & slip resistant handle.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • NSF approved.
Check Price
Oyster Shucking Knife & Gloves
  • Blade Length: 2.5"
  • Includes level-5 cut resistant gloves.
  • Colored 4" wood handle.
  • High carbon blade.
Check Price
Rockland Guard Oyster Shucking Knife
  • Blade Length: 3.5"
  • Comes in a set of four.
  • Non slip handle w/ guard.
  • Stainless steel blade.
  • Dishwasher safe.
Check Price

Top 5 Best Oyster Knives

1. Dexter New Haven Style Oyster Knife – Best for Quality & Durability

Features:
  • Blade Length: 2.75″
  • Made in the USA.
  • High carbon & alloy blade.
  • NSF Certified.
  • Bent-tip.

Dexter’s New Haven style oyster knife boasts an extremely well made construction and is much more durable than the other options on this list. It’s manufactured by an American company that uses a high carbon, high alloy stainless steel blade that is much stronger than the other oyster knives we’ve reviewed. It’s handle is also ergonomic and ridged to help prevent slips even when wet.

This knife makes quick work of even stubborn to open oysters thanks to it’s bent tip and their proprietary steel construction. It’s recommended that you hand wash this knife after use since a dishwasher can potentially damage the handle of the knife. That being said, many people have reported no problems to just throwing this in the dishwasher but the manufacturer still recommends cleaning by hand.

If you’re looking for downsides to this knife, you’re going to be hard pressed to find them. It’s hands down the best constructed oyster knife we’ve ever reviewed and it’s very competitively priced. It’s no wonder that Dexter is the industry standard for even commercial oyster shuckers, this knife really is perfect.

Pros
  • Extremely well constructed.
  • NSF Certified.
  • The tip of the knife is bent for easier prying.
  • In addition to being ergonomic, the handle is ridged to help prevent slips even when wet.

Cons
  • Not recommended for dishwashers, will need to hand clean after use.

Buy at Amazon.com

2. OXO Good Grip Oyster Knife – Best for Slip Resistance

Features:
  • Stainless steel blade.
  • Made in China.
  • Bent tip for easier prying.
  • Soft and slip-resistant handle.
  • 100% Dishwasher safe.

The OXO Good Grip is an excellent choice for those looking for a great, slip resistant oyster shucking knife. It’s soft handle rests ergonomically in your hand for added comfort and the non-slip handle actively helps prevent accidents. The tip of the blade itself is also bent to make prying open the oysters even easier. And after you’re finished you can safely toss the knife into the dishwasher as it’s completely dishwasher safe!

Really the only downside is that really tough oysters can sometimes bend the blade, though it’s fairly uncommon to do so. To prevent bends we recommend slowly increasing the pressure and repositioning the knife to try to gain more leverage without putting so much pressure on the blade itself.

Pros
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • Non-slip handle.
  • The blade is made of stainless steel.
  • The bent tip makes it easier to pry open oysters.

Cons
  • The blade itself is prone to bending under heavy strain.

Buy at Amazon.com

3. Victorinox Oyster Knife – Best for Cherrystone Oysters

Features:
  • Blade Length: 2.75″
  • Made in Switzerland.
  • Ergonomic & slip resistant handle.
  • Dishwasher safe.
  • NSF approved.

The Swiss made Victorinox oyster knife comes in a variety of different models and styles depending on your individually needs. For instance, the 4″ Boston oyster knife comes with a thinner blade that is better at penetrating the hinge of the oyster. On the other hand, the New Haven blade is curved which makes it perfect for cherrystone sized oysters.

Regardless of which type of blade you select you can expect quality and durability. The handle is slip resistant and very ergonomic while still maintaining it’s compact form. The blade itself is made of a very high carbon steel which dramatically increases it’s strength and makes it very difficult to bend under normal circumstances.

As far as weaknesses go, the tip of the blade is a bit prone to damage. It’s really the only downside to an otherwise great oyster shucking knife – you need to be careful not to apply too much pressure onto the tip of the knife or it may chip and break off.

Pros
  • Several different types of blades depending on your individual needs.
  • Completely dishwasher safe.
  • NSF approved.
  • Slip resistant and comfortable handle.

Cons
  • Under heavy stress the tip of the knife may bend or chip off.

Buy at Amazon.com

4. Oyster Shucking Knife & Gloves – Best for Knife & Glove Combo

Features:
  • Blade Length: 2.5″
  • Includes level-5 cut resistant gloves.
  • Colored 4″ wood handle.
  • High carbon blade.

For those in specific need of both an oyster shucking knife and gloves then this kit is for you. In addition to the high carbon, 6.5″ long oyster shucking knife it also includes a pair of level five cut resistant gloves that come in three sizes: medium, large and extra large. It even includes a leather storage case for when the knife isn’t in use.

Gloves are strongly recommended to prevent any potential accidents while shucking oysters. While these gloves aren’t exactly perfect, they’re good enough to prevent potential cuts or abrasions and are relatively easy to clean.

Unlike many of the options on this list, the blade itself isn’t curved so it may be a bit tougher to open some oysters with. On the upside, though, you can use this knife to open clams as well so it’s a great all-round at opening shellfish.

Pros
  • Works well for left or right handed people.
  • Comes with a leather storage case.
  • The handle is long and made of wood.
  • Comes with level five cut resistant gloves.
  • Great price for what it comes with.

Cons
  • The gloves run a bit on the small side.
  • The blade isn’t curved.

Buy at Amazon.com

5. Rockland Guard Oyster Shucking Knife – Best for Bulk Oyster Shuckers

Features:
  • Blade Length: 3.5″
  • Comes in a set of four.
  • Non slip handle w/ guard.
  • Stainless steel blade.
  • Dishwasher safe.

We selected this knife specifically for those that are looking for bulk oyster shucking knives that won’t break the bank. Sold in a set of four, the Rockland oyster knife comes with a 3.5″ length blade and an ergonomic grip that is both slip resistant and includes a convenient guard to prevent accidents. Even the blade is stainless steel and completely dishwasher safe!

That being said, if you don’t specifically need a large set of knives then you may be better suited ordering them individually. You’ll definitely save money by ordering in bulk but for most consumers they simply won’t need four individual oyster shucking knives.

Pros
  • Most cost effective on a per-knife basis.
  • Sold in a set of four.
  • The handle is slip resistant and comes with a protective guard.
  • Safe to use in your dishwasher.

Cons
  • While it may be cheaper to buy in bulk, for most consumers you probably won’t need four separate oyster shucking knives.

Buy at Amazon.com

Conclusion

The 5 oyster knives that we’ve reviewed above are easily the cream of the crop. And of those 5 the Dexter New Haven Style Oyster Knife is our all around choice for the best oyster knife.

On the other hand if you need a oyster knife that includes cut resistant gloves then we’d suggest the Oyster Shucking Knife & Gloves.

Buyer’s Guide

Buying a oyster knife is pretty straightforward once you realize which features you absolutely must have. In order to help you identify which features are critically important we wrote a buyer’s guide that breaks down the important aspects you need to know about before placing an order.

Construction

Stronger blades tend to be an alloy of high carbon steel that significantly helps prevent breaks and bends. These are strongly recommended since oysters have a bad habit of being quite stubborn to open and it isn’t uncommon to bend blades while applying pressure. Be sure to check the manufacturer’s specifications before ordering to make sure the blade you choose can hold up against even the toughest to open oysters.

Thickness

The thickness of the knife is also an important factor to take into consideration. The thinner knives tend to be easier to penetrate the hinge of the oyster so you can more effectively get into the oyster with it. The downside is that thinner knives are generally less durable and are thus more likely to bend or break under heavy strain. If you do opt for a thinner knife, be sure to choose one that is strongly constructed so you don’t have to worry about it breaking.

New Haven Style

New Haven oyster knives are generally shorter and feature a wider blade with a pointed tip that curves ever so slightly upward. That curved tip helps significantly in the shucking of oysters since it allows you to avoid damaging the meat while still giving you the leverage and strength you need to pry it open. It’s recommended that when using a New Haven knife that you shuck the oyster from the hinge and not from the sides.

Boston Style

Boston oyster shucking knives feature a straight and narrower blade with a rounded tip that makes it ideal for shucking oysters from the side rather than from the hinge. The blades are also a bit longer – generally 3.5 to 4 inches long.

Galveston Style

Galveston oyster shucking knives are just like Boston knives in that they’re long and have a rounded tip but they’re usually wider which makes them an ideal candidate for shucking larger oysters. Just like Boston knives you should enter the clam from the side and not from the hinge.

Warranty

Be sure to check whether or not the manufacturer offers a warranty on the item you intend to purchase. While Amazon should cover broken or defective items upon delivery, it’s up to the manufacturer as to whether they will provide a replacement after it’s been used. Compare different oyster knife sellers to see if any of them will offer replacements in the event it breaks from normal use.

Return Policy

Even if everything works properly, you may discover you’ve ordered the wrong oyster knife for your needs which may require a return. Be sure to check with the vendor before purchasing to see if they will allow a return and if so, under what circumstances.

Shipping

Shipping is easily one of the most annoying costs associated with making online purchases. Be sure to compare the shipping costs to your location prior to making a purchase so you don’t end up spending more than you bargained for.

Frequently Asked Questions

Which oyster knife is the cheapest?

If you’re shopping for the lowest priced oyster knife you can find then we recommend the Dexter New Haven Style Oyster Knife. Of all the oyster knives we’ve reviewed, none of the others can beat it’s price.

Can you shuck oysters with a regular knife?

Probably not. Oysters are notoriously difficult to open and will bend or break most standard knives that try to open them. You might be able to make it work with a very strong paring knife, but you’ll likely save yourself a lot of damaged knives by just buying an oyster shucking knife and using that.

What is the difference between clam knives and oyster knives?

Oyster knives can feature either a straight or curved blade with a pointed or curved tip whereas clam knives tend to be very thin and flat. Some oyster knives can also be used to open clams but you’ll want to check the manufacturer’s specifications before trying so you don’t damage it. Generally speaking, if the knife is straight and flat you can probably open clams with it if it’s strong enough.

What can I use if I don’t have an oyster knife?

In a pinch a screwdriver will work to open oysters with. It’s definitely not elegant or quick, but if you don’t have an oyster knife a screwdriver can work.

How do you open oysters with an oyster shucking knife?

  1. Place the oyster on the table with the cup side down the side that isn’t flat) so that when you open it the juice won’t spill out.
  2. Find the hinge of the oyster that looks a bit like the V and insert the tip of the blade into it.
  3. Wiggle the knife back and forth with a small amount of force until it’s about a 1/3 of an inch inside the oyster.
  4. Try to pry the oyster open by twisting the blade. If you feel some resistance then keep twisting and it will open right up. If it doesn’t open or move at all don’t force it or you may break the shell.
  5. After the oyster is opened completely insert the blade and begin cutting around the muscle that is holding it closed.
  6. Remove the top shell and cut the muscle that holds the oyster to the bottom shell so it isn’t sticking at all to the shell.
  7. Add your desired seasoning and enjoy!
For those who are more visual learners, here’s a great video that shows the whole process from beginning to end:

Further Reading